So, we asked the people across the street if they saw anything. We think they did it with their geo. After I asked the woman (who says she wasn’t home yesterday) they both came out, looked at the front of the geo and drove away.

We have a refletor that was sitting next the scene of the crime.
If anyone can identify GM part 5973678LR2 (or part 16500312 2) from a GEO tracker. Let me know. I’d like to know for sure if it is or isn’t him.

Update:I called the police. He seems to think that it was some teenagers in stolen cars. He doesn’t think it was the neighbors. I still find it suspicious they looked at their car and drove off. I hope to catch them coming home so I can see for sure.